"Rules: Logic and Applications" 2nd Workshop, Dec, 2019
Aesthetic Morphisms
Jocelyn Ireson-Paine
www.jocelyns-cartoons.uk/rules2019/
Contents Previous Next
Slides as PDF Artistic Techniques Database Demo Artistic Techniques Database Video Contact

Cubism: What Were They Thinking Of?

What the Cubists had done was to create a new image of reality, influenced to some extent by the radical theories of the French philosopher Henri Bergson. Rejecting any conception of painting as a kind of window on the world', they broke decisively with the post-Renaissance convention of depicting objects as if seen from a single viewpoint, employing instead what Metzinger called 'mobile perspective' — moving round objects, simultaneously recording not only different images of the same object, but also the near and the far, the seen and the remembered. The more radical also analysed, probed, destroyed objects in order to reconstruct them, enhancing the emphasis given to the surface plane of the picture while at the same time progressively blurring the separation between the motif (figure, object, etc.) and its environment.
— From Peter Vergo's Introduction to Abstraction: Towards a New Art: Painting 1910-20.

Compositionally, Violin and Palette is a simple picture. A violin dominates the bottom two-thirds of the canvas, sitting beneath some sheet music that rests on a stand. Above that is a painter's palette hanging from a nail in the wall, to the side of which is a green curtain. Braque has continued with Cézanne's subdued palette of pale greens and browns. Not this time, though, as an homage, but out of necessity. He realized, as did Picasso, that only by using a muted palette could he successfully blend multiple viewpoints of the same subject on a single canvas — a variety of bright colours would be impossible to configure for the artist and would present us with an indecipherable mess. Instead, they devised a technique where a straight line would mark a change of view, while subtle tonal shading would demonstrate to the viewer that a transition was taking place. The added benefit of this approach was an overall design that was balanced and coherent.
— Will Gompertz, What Are You Looking At?: 150 Years of Modern Art in the Blink of an Eye.

They are metaphors of relativity and connection; in them, the world is imagined as a network of fleeting events, a twitching skin of nuances. Fragments of lettering (BAL, MA JOLIE, a bar bill reading 10.40, a musical clef) and clues to real things (the strings and sound-hole of the guitar in Braque's Portuguese❞
— Robert Hughes, The Shock of the New: Art and the Century of Change.

BUT

The quotes above state that Cubism was intended to give more information to the viewer than perspective does. However, this may be a misunderstanding of the Cubists' intentions, derived from mis-explanations published at the time. Instead, Cubism was exclusively concerned with unifying the picture: "flattening" depicted objects by reducing their shading and colour, so that they merged into the flatness of the canvas.
— Summarised from Hal Foster, Rosalind Krauss, Yve-Alain Bois, Benjamin H. D. Buchloh, Art Since 1900.